The primary question in many toxic tort cases is what caused the disease? When defending these cases, one necessarily asks: (1) is the product/substance I am defending capable of causing the disease in question; and (2) was the plaintiff exposed to enough of it to have done so.
With cases involving cancer, particularly mesothelioma, genetic science is adding to the mix and providing information that, in the right case, changes the equation entirely.
Generally, cancer is a genetic disease caused by gene mutations that control how cells grow and multiply (NIH The Genetics of Cancer, 2022). While cells are the bodys building blocks, genes are sections of DNA in each cell that provide instructions to make required proteins and control cell growth. Hundreds of DNA and genetic changes (variants, mutations or alterations) have been discovered that help cancer form, grow and spread.
My experience with these issues arises from the defense of asbestos cases. The principles raised, however, may well apply to other toxic torts involving cancer.
It is now recognized that there are multiple causes for malignant mesothelioma, a number of which are unrelated to asbestos. Diffuse malignant mesotheliomas are variably associated with prior asbestos exposure, and the strength of the association varies with anatomical tumor site, gender and asbestos fiber type.
The relationship between asbestos and mesothelioma has also evolved and shows significant geographic variation. The epidemiological evidence correlating time trends, incidence by gender, and commercial asbestos use indicates that a majority of pleural mesotheliomas in women, and almost all peritoneal mesotheliomas in women and men, in the United States, appear unrelated to asbestos.
In July 2019, many of the worlds foremost experts on the subject detailed the current state-of-the-art knowledge on the development of mesothelioma. See Carbone, et al., Mesothelioma: Scientific Clues for Prevention, Diagnosis, and Therapy, CA Cancer J Clin., 69:402-429 (2019).
Among the co-authors of the publication were preeminent researchers and practitioners from the University of Hawaii Cancer Center, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, Brigham and Womens Hospital, Mayo Clinic, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, and MD Anderson Cancer Center. Under a section of the publication entitled The Role of Genetics, the authors state:
When examining a toxic tort/cancer case, it may not always be the environment or the toxin that is the culprit. If a plaintiff has an appropriate family history of cancer, genetic testing may provide a viable defense.
Cancer is caused by the accumulation of genetic damage. Genetic damage can be inherited, can develop spontaneously, can be caused by exposure to carcinogens and oncogenic infectious agents, or can be caused by the interplay of a combination of these factors. Currently, there is a very active debate about the relative contribution of these factors to human cancer . [A] growing percentage of cancers are attributed to inherited mutations of DNA repair genes and of other genes that, when mutated, accelerate the accumulation of DNA damage and/or the percentage of cells carrying DNA damage . These concepts apply to mesothelioma.
In broad strokes, there are two types of genetic cases: (1) cases involving somatic or random genetic mutations; and (2) cases involving a germline genetic mutation.
Somatic random mutations develop because of DNA changes that occur during stem cell divisions. These mutations arise naturally and accumulate as a person ages. Age is a significant risk factor for almost all forms of cancer, including spontaneous or naturally occurring mesothelioma.
The basis for age-induced tumorigenesis relates to the hosts generation of critical driver mutations within cells and the subsequent formation of clonally expanded proliferation of mutated cells to form tumors. Stem cell division occurs continuously and requires a faithful replication of the highly complex genetic information contained within the genome and cell nucleus.
Random mistakes or mutations (replication errors) occur continuously and with increasing frequency over time, with the capacity of the host to efficiently identify and correct such mutations diminishing with age.
Because mutation accumulation occurs spontaneously and continuously over time, the risk of spontaneous or naturally occurring mesothelioma, either pleural or peritoneal, increases continuously with age.
Random mutations account for two-thirds of the risk of getting many types of cancer. In such cases, no exposure to an exogenous agent (such as asbestos or therapeutic radiation) is required for tumor initiation. Replicative mutations can be responsible for either initiating the process or driving tumor progression.
The current best available scientific evidence is that some mesotheliomas are linked to inherited germline mutations. Overall, at least 12 percent of mesotheliomas occur in carriers of germline genetic mutations. These germline genetic-induced mesotheliomas typically occur in persons of younger age and are often peritoneal rather than pleural mesotheliomas.
As the cohorts of asbestos workers vanish due to old age, increasing percentages of mesotheliomas, especially peritoneal mesotheliomas, occur in individuals who are not occupationally exposed to asbestos. These mesotheliomas may be caused by environmental exposure, genetic predisposition or both.
Pathogenic germline mutations of BAP1 and, less frequently, of other tumor suppressor genes have also been detected in approximately 12 percent of patients. This subgroup of genetically linked mesotheliomas occurs in younger individuals who rarely report asbestos exposure, and with a M:F ratio of 1:1 and survival ranging from five to 10 or more years.
While heritable gene mutations can predispose an individual to cancer (i.e., lower the amount of exposure necessary to cause disease), they can also be sufficient to cause cancers, including mesothelioma, in and of themselves.
Put another way, the presence of a heritable germline mutation, absent or independent of extrinsic factors such as asbestos exposure, can be a cause of mesothelioma.
While the import of these findings may be largely self-evident, there are some takeaways worth considering. First, when examining a toxic tort/cancer case, it may not always be the environment or the toxin that is the culprit. If a plaintiff has an appropriate family history of cancer, genetic testing may provide a viable defense.
Second, genetic germline mutations do not automatically turn a plaintiff into an eggshell plaintiff. While that argument may work in some cases, given that the mutation can be independently causative, it should not apply in all of them.
Anthony J. Sbarra is a shareholder at Segal McCambridge in Boston and focuses his practice on product liability and toxic tort cases.
Continued here:
Significance of genetic mutations in toxic tort cases - Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly
- Introgression and disruption of migration routes have shaped the genetic integrity of wildebeest populations - Nature.com - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Is Left-Handedness Tied to Your Genetics? Possibly, New Study Suggests - Technology Networks - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- A pan-genome of 69 Arabidopsis thaliana accessions reveals a conserved genome structure throughout the global ... - Nature.com - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Clemson researchers pave the way for precision medicine with AI - Clemson News - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- ACMG Foundation for Genetic and Genomic Medicine Elects Four Highly Accomplished Medical Genetics ... - PR Newswire - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Katie Gallagher MS '15, CGC Named Director of the Joan H. Marks Graduate Program in Human Genetics at Sarah ... - Sarah Lawrence College - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- The genomic architecture of inherited DNA variants - Baylor College of Medicine | BCM - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Clemson genetics major named Truman Scholar for her work in combatting rare diseases - ABC NEWS 4 - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Otago University Discovers Cause of Rare Genetic Condition - Mirage News - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Genetic Analysis Guides Conservation of Endangered Bumble Bee - Entomology Today - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- First insights into the genetic bottleneck characterizing early sheep husbandry in the Neolithic period - EurekAlert - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Protein-truncating variants in BSN are associated with severe adult-onset obesity, type 2 diabetes and fatty liver disease - Nature.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- A deep dive into the genetics of alcohol consumption - Medical Xpress - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Right-wing authoritarianism appears to have a genetic foundation - PsyPost - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- UC Irvine-led research team builds first tandem repeat expansions genetic reference maps - UCI News - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- A Deep Dive Into the Genetics of Alcohol Consumption - University of California San Diego - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Untold story of bird evolution revealed through genetics - Earth.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Genetic Test for Opioid Addiction Risk Should Be Withdrawn, Experts Tell FDA - Medpage Today - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Scientists Discover 17 New Genetic Variants Linked to Alzheimer's Disease - SciTechDaily - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- An hereditary liver disease cured with the help of gene scissors - EurekAlert - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- World Anthropology Day showcases multifaceted programs | Binghamton News - Binghamton University - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Resilience to periodic disturbances and the long-term genetic stability in Acropora coral | Communications Biology - Nature.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Rare genetic variants found to have a large impact on obesity risk - Drug Target Review - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- INTERACT COALITION FORMED TO ADVANCE PATIENT ACCESS TO GENETIC TESTING FOR HEREDITARY ... - PR Newswire - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Christensen Genetics - AG INFORMATION NETWORK OF THE WEST - AGInfo Ag Information Network - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- New form of EDS identified by mutation in THBS2 gene - Ehlers-Danlos News - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Genetics of estrogen production linked to endometrial cancer risk in postmenopausal women - News-Medical.Net - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Cord Blood Registry (CBR) by CooperSurgical and Fulgent Genetics Launch Innovative Genetic Testing - PR Newswire - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Gene Variant Linked to Lower Levels of Hormonal Birth Control - The Scientist - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- CooperSurgical, Fulgent partner on genetic screening panels - Medical Device Network - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- UM Today | Faculty of Science | The intersection of genetics and advocacy - UM Today - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Genome-wide association study identifies human genetic variants associated with fatal outcome from Lassa fever - Nature.com - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Secrets of human genetics could optimize medical care - Earth.com - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Significance of genetic mutations in toxic tort cases - Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Why Should Farmers Invest in New Genetics? A Recent Panel Discussion Offered Some Good Reasons - Seed World - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- The Role of Genetics and Maternal Factors in Retinopathy of Prematurity: A Comparative Study - Medriva - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- 'The Idea That Who You Are Is Only Genetics Is the Essence of Evil' - Books - Haaretz - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- IPK researchers provide genetic explanations for shade-induced biomass allocation in wheat - EurekAlert - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- River Valley Beef Cattle Conference to explore state of hay availability, cattle genetics and more - Stuttgart Daily Leader - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Harnessing human evolution to advance precision medicine - EurekAlert - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Twins are a mirror to each other and a window into the mysteries of genetics - WAMU 88.5 - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Unveiling the Disparity in Cardiovascular Health: Biological Factors, Dyslipidemia, and Genetics - Medriva - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Parental traits offer new clues to predicting neurodevelopmental disorders in children - News-Medical.Net - February 13th, 2024 [February 13th, 2024]
- Cheetahs Are Extremely Inbred: 50 Interesting Genetics Facts You May Have Missed At School - Bored Panda - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Five Best: Books on Genetics - WSJ - The Wall Street Journal - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- 4 new US sites added to global Parkinson's genetics study - Parkinson's News Today - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Animal Genetics Market revenue to exceed USD 43.4 Billion by 2036, says Research Nester - Yahoo Finance - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Nobel Laureate and World-Renowned Geneticist to Speak at 2024 Commencement - News Center - Feinberg News Center - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Efforts are underway to improve genetics in cattle herds to better sustainability - RFD-TV - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- First report on the molecular phylogenetics and population genetics of Aedes aegypti in Iran - Parasites & Vectors - Parasites & Vectors - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- What can your DNA say about your risk of opioid addiction? - National Geographic - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- The Born in Guangzhou Cohort Study enables generational genetic discoveries - Nature.com - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Invitae Partners with BridgeBio Pharma to Harness Genetic Insights for the Discovery of Rare Disease Therapeutics - PR Newswire - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Rare disorder causing extra fingers and toes identified - EurekAlert - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Retinal OCT and Genetics Identify Links Between Ocular and Systemic Health - Photonics.com - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Researchers discover mechanism that protects tissue after faulty gene expression - News-Medical.Net - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Genetics or lifestyle: What makes the greatest difference in health? - Agweek - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Why Some Folks Get COVID, and Others Never Do - HealthDay - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- From plant genetics to fresh produce to be showcased in Berlin - FreshPlaza.com - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Adolescent Stress Alters Brain Genes, Affecting Adult Behavior - Neuroscience News - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- New genetic test in England aims to make blood transfusions safer - Sickle Cell Disease News - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Unlocking tree genetic diversity: advanced hyperspectral phenotyping for enhanced Scots pine selection - EurekAlert - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- The Role of Genetics in Cancer Care Continues to Expand - OncLive - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Family faces multiple diagnoses for genetic condition NF1 - Sanford Health News - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Unique gene variants tied to glaucoma found in Black patients - Livescience.com - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Myriad Genetics to Acquire Precise Tumor, Precise Liquid and Laboratory from Intermountain Precision Genomics - GlobeNewswire - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Reflections on the Idea of Social and Behavioral Genetics - The Hastings Center - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Building trust and saving lives: A community approach to genetic education - Medical University of South Carolina - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- SOPHiA GENETICS and Karkinos Healthcare Forge Strategic Partnership to Advance Cancer Research in India India ... - PR Newswire - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- 2024 Brevant Brand Corn Class Offers New Genetics and Traits - CropLife - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Genetics Reveal Poor Oral Health in Mesolithic Era - Mirage News - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Nova Siri Genetics strengthens its presence in Huelva, growing by 34% - FreshPlaza.com - January 19th, 2024 [January 19th, 2024]
- Controversial New Research Find That Bisexuals Are a Bunch of Rascals - Futurism - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- Mayo Clinic Q&A: Weight loss and genetics - Chicago Tribune - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- Nutrigene Launches Personalised Development Program to Intersect Genetics and Learning through DNA - JCN Newswire - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- The DNA of privacy and the privacy of DNA - Federal Trade Commission News - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- Development of a human genetics-guided priority score for 19365 genes and 399 drug indications - Nature.com - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- Myriad Genetics, Inc.'s (NASDAQ:MYGN) Intrinsic Value Is Potentially 221% Above Its Share Price - Yahoo Finance - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- Educational attainment of East Asians are linked to genetics - KBR - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]
- MESuSiE enables scalable and powerful multi-ancestry fine-mapping of causal variants in genome-wide association ... - Nature.com - January 8th, 2024 [January 8th, 2024]