Alexander Payne makes movies about unlikeable, obsolete men, and then leaves us to wonder whether theyre obsolete because theyre unlikable or unlikable because theyre obsolete. The people around them, especially the women, just seem so much more functional, adept at adjusting to times that arent a-changin nearly as swiftly as the cranky protagonists contend. Paynes films can feel like special pleading, especially if youve ever had to tussle with the learned helplessness of such a male, or if you suspect that, despite your best efforts, youve devolved into one yourself.
In The Holdovers we meet the latest addition to Paynes roster of curmudgeons, Paul Hunham, a staple in many high schools and probably every single prep school: the sexless (if not virginal) odd-smelling disciplinarian. Its 1970 and Hunham, played by Paul Giamatti, is a teacher of ancient history at the Barton Academy and a graduate of that fictional Massachusetts school as well. The kids call him Walleye (at last, representation for us lazy-eyed humans), as do some of his colleagues, too, and hes such a hard ass the headmaster (a former student) holds a grudge against him.
As a result, Hunham is condemned to spending Christmas break with five students who have no home to go to for the season. (Its not much of a sacrificeHunham seems to have nowhere to go anyhow.) There are two young kids (one Mormon, one Korean) and three older students: an absolute asshole named Teddy, a football player in a battle of wills with his dad, and bright-yet-underachieving Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), who brandishes a truly formidable Adams apple.
At this point, were primed for some sort of Breakfast Clubby interaction between Hunham and the five mismatched holdovers, where everyone learns a little lesson about each other, but Payne swerves away from that simple resolution. Instead the film centers on the relationship between Paul and Angus, which evolves from purely adversarial to a wary kind of trust and respect. Intervening between them is school cook Mary Lamb (Da'Vine Joy Randolph), whose son, a former student at Barton, died in Vietnam; Paul and Mary bond over The Newlywed Game and Canadian Club and their resentment of the prep students' brattiness.
In typical Payne fashion, characters fumble into romantic cul-de-sacs, secret pasts are revealed, and misanthropes are slowly humanized. Reasons emerge for characters to go off campus, and, like leaving the boat in Apocalypse Now, there are consequences each time, some more comic than others. The Holdovers rambles a bit, but thats a positiveit doesnt lead us exactly where we expect it to, even if it doesnt take us anywhere particularly unfamiliar.
In recent years, of course, Payne has been in danger of becoming obsolete himself. After the success of Sideways in 2004 he began work on a passion project, Downsizing, surfacing periodically for decent-to-good films in the interim before the messy results of his long obsession were released in 2017. The Holdovers returns him to the politics of the classroom broached in Election, reunites him with Sidewayss Giamatti, and comes as close to a crowd pleaser as Payne dares. Its a satisfying return to form, if youd like a quote for the trailer, and Paynes Wikipedia page even has a hopeful and perhaps premature section tagged 2023present: Resurgence.
But phoniness creeps in around the edges of The Holdovers. Though the movie was shot digitally, Payne indulges in a grubby nostalgia, with effects designed to simulate the grain of 70s film. Its as though he doesnt just want his film to recall the era when it was set, but also to return us to an age when movies were movies. Some of these choices are effectivecinematographer Eigil Bryld achieves a masterfully bleak Christmastime look. Yet in making a film about the kind of film that existed 50 years ago, Payne draws unflattering comparisons to his cinematic betters, and makes us question his motives.
Why 1970, after all? True, a whiff of antiauthoritarianism is in the airor maybe thats just some contraband ditchweed. The rebellious atmosphere at Barton is mild, marked by a little pot, a little porn, some hair below the shirt collar. (One way prep schools contain revolt is by giving kids arbitrary rules to break, so you can feel like a rebel just by loosening your tie.) Vietnam does linger in the backgroundas a place where the underprivileged are killed or maimed, and in the threat from Anguss parents to send him to military schoolbut it feels like more of a dramatic device than a real presence in the characters lives.
Still, the slightly old-fashioned moral drama Payne sets up here could only play out in a time (were meant to believe) when you knew which rules it was appropriate to break and when. Payne requires an entrenched institutional authority so he can tell a story about how important it is to honor the humane spirit of the law rather than slavishly follow its draconian letter. Thats a pretty fuckin weird thing to do when you think about it.
Especially as its third-act revelations roll in, the humanization of the characters can feel a bit mechanical if youre not in the mood. I usually feel like Im being worked over in Paynes movies, and often I push back. But here the cast coaxed me along for the ride. As Hunham, Giamatti plays a man who has calcified into a caricature. The affectations he may have once thought were flippantly acerbic are now tics, and his code of honor, which he wields with a not-unreasonable sense of class resentment, is brittle as well, a defense he developed for long-past battles. Sessa is the perfect foil, not a rebel in any sense, just a kid stifled by his parents and his surroundings. And though Marys arc is a bit too delineatedwe know exactly what she has to process and its just a question of figuring out howRandolphs performance does feel true to life.
In the end, The Holdovers comes down to lessons learned and sacrifices made, and Hunham is given a dramatic opportunity to exercise his nobility. Theres a constant tug between the actors striving to inhabit their characters and explore their complexities and Payne limiting them to the roles he needs them to play. But honestly, if this was as hokey as movies ever got, especially as Oscar season rolled around, this would be a fine world indeed.
***
Theres not much point in complaining about a movies marketing, especially at a time when getting anyone in a theater is a challenge, but the website for Anatomy of Fall really does a disservice to Justine Triets carefully balanced courtroom drama. Not only is the domain didshedoit.com, but upon loading the page youre immediately given two big YES or NO block options to click to enter the site, which reduces a prolonged, fraught examination on the slippery nature of truth and evidence into a parlor game. Arent we allowed even a little tiny bit of ambiguity anymore?
The films setup is simple, with just enough elements in play to make what happened uncertain to the viewer. Sandra (Sandra Hller), an established novelist, and her husband, Samuel (Samuel Theis), a teacher and significantly less successful writer, live in Grenoble, his hometown in France, with their partially blind son Daniel (Milo Machado Graner). On the day of Samuels death, a student named Zo (Camille Rutherford) comes to their home to interview Sandra, and their discussion turns to the prickly question of how a writers life is reflected in her work.
Midway through their talk, Samuel, who is remodeling the attic, starts blasting an instrumental version of 50 Cents P.I.M.P. so loudly the two women cant continue. Zo drives away, and at around the same time, Daniel and his seeing-eye dog Snoop leave for a walk, and the camera leaves with them. When Daniel comes home, he finds his father dead on the ground outside their home, the attic window above open.
This brief series of events provides the grist for the film that follows. As shes transformed in the eyes of the law from grieving widow to prime suspect, Sandra responds with unsettling reserve, and her lawyer, Vincent (Swann Arlaud), has to convince her of the danger shes in. Were left to wonder whether shes as icy as she seems or if shes stunned by how swiftly the apparatus of justice zeroes in on her.
Investigators overrun her home, requiring her to re-enact conversations with her late husband and to watch a dummy representing his body drop repeatedly from the window. A guardian (Jehnny Beth of the band Savages) is appointed by the court to oversee Daniel, who becomes a key witness.
Once were in the courtroom, with facts exculpatory and damning slowly trickling out, the plot of Anatomy of a Fall becomes a kind of austere pulp, its subject matter juicy but its mood somewhat rigorous. Anchoring that tone is Hller, who first achieved widespread attention as the straight-laced daughter of a madcap father in Toni Erdmann and has been celebrated this year for her role as the wife of a Nazi commandant in Jonathan Glazers well-reviewed The Zone of Interest. Shes so composed that were not waiting for her to crack, as we might with a more conventional performance. But crack she does, and with something more than a typical dramatic burst, because Hller shows a woman not just defending herself but defending her fundamental belief in the complexity of human motive, a belief shes loath to surrender for the sake of proving her innocence.
But reluctantly, Sandra learns that she has to set aside her novelists beliefs in the unknowability of the human heart and to offer an opposing believable narrative to the prosecution's. Samuel was suicidal, she implies, and he jumped to his death. But as we learn more details about the relationship between Sandra and Samuel, her faith in complexity is affirmed. A couple creates a sort of third entity between two people that can never be wholly understood from the outside. We have countless motives for concealing or altering the truth, and any conversation with a partner can make you sound like a potential murderer.
For an American, theres always something particularly compelling about a European courtroom dramathe dramatic elements are similar but the ground rules are different. While watching Anatomy of a Fall. I couldnt help but think of Alice Diops Saint Omer, another recent French courtroom drama about a woman on trial with a stunning central performance. A very different movie, a very different woman, a very different performance, but in both cases what we watch feels less like a woman on trial and more like a trial happening to a woman.
Because were so close to Sandra the entire time, we instinctively root for her, even though shes far from an ingratiating character. No guilty person could possibly be so reluctant to play the games of justice, could she? And Antoine Reinartz is unnerving as the prosecutor with a shaved head and a condescendingly stooped gait, swooping in with vicious questions and then retreating smugly to his post. Shes painted as a woman who has insisted on having time for her work (i.e., a bad mother) and who had affairs at that. And language complicates the story as well: Sandra is German but is forced to speak French in the courtroom most of the time.
All Triet has to do for Anatomy of a Fall to work is not show what happened. Yet even after a verdict is reached, the air isnt entirely cleared. The more evidence that were given, the less certain we are of everything. Far from an invitation to speculate, however, that seems to be the point: actual truth and legal truth are not identical. How or if you choose the websites cheap questiondid she do it?says more about you than it does about the film.
GRADES
The Holdovers B+ Anatomy of a Fall A-
Read the original post:
'The Holdovers' and 'Anatomy of a Fall' Play Truth or Consequences ... - Racket
- 'Grey's Anatomy': Meredith's Family Emergency Brings Up the Past - PEOPLE - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Cristina Yang's Return Prospect Gets Honest Response From Sandra Oh - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' recap: Is Jo pregnant? - Entertainment Weekly News - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Shonda Rhimes had police protect her after 'Grey's Anatomy' finales - Business Insider - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Most Enduring Character Is a Real-Life Scrub Nurse - CBR - Comic Book Resources - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Civil War | Anatomy of a Scene - The New York Times - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- How Frances Anatomy of a Fall Scored a Theatrical Release in China and Connected With Its Elusive Indie Audience - Variety - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Station 19 Season 7 Just Reversed A Major Grey's Anatomy Story With Sully & Natasha - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Why Sandra Oh Doesn't Plan to Return to 'Grey's Anatomy' 'Anytime Soon' - PEOPLE - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Confirms A Fatal Flaw In Meredith's Story After 20 Seasons - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Jo Is 'Spiraling' from Pregnancy News (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Would Sandra Oh ever come back to 'Grey's Anatomy'? - New York Post - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Why Did Sarah Drew Leave Grey's Anatomy? - CBR - Comic Book Resources - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- How to watch Greys Anatomy season 20 episode 5 for free - MassLive.com - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20, Episode 5 Recap: 6 Biggest Story Reveals - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- How Shonda Rhimes Celebrated the 20th Season of 'Grey's Anatomy' And Yet Another History-Making Moment for ... - Shondaland.com - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Station 19: Ben & Carina's Grey's Anatomy Futures Carefully Teased By Showrunner - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- 10 Best Ellen Pompeo Movie and TV Show Roles That Aren't Grey's Anatomy - CBR - Comic Book Resources - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Cristina Yang's Return Prospect Gets Honest Response From Sandra Oh - imdb - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Meredith Was Missing Derek After Son's Medical Emergency, But Here's Why I Think She And Nick ... - CinemaBlend - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- The Anatomy of An Inning: Brayan Bello Attacks the A's - Over The Monster - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- A slice of life inside the Human Anatomy Lab at Cal Poly - Mustang News - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- SynthFest France 2024 coming April 19-21 with Synth Anatomy video coverage - Synth Anatomy - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Sandra Oh weighs in on Christina Yang return - Digital Spy - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Just Teased The Show's Next Great Couple - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- The Art of Medieval Anatomy with Taylor McCall - Medievalists.net - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Anatomy of a Fall Actor Samuel Theis Accused of Rape by Crew Member on New Film - Yahoo Movies Canada - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Anatomy Of A Recession Update: What's Different About This Cycle? - Seeking Alpha - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Renewed For Season 21 By ABC - Deadline - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy to highlight Baton Rouge baby's rare medical case Thursday night - WBRZ - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- A Refresher on What Happened to Arizona on 'Grey's Anatomy' - Parade Magazine - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- How the 'Grey's Anatomy' Crew Works With Real-Life Doctors to Bring The Most Complicated Procedures to TV - Shondaland.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 (ABC): What We Know So Far - Parade Magazine - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20: Premiere Date, Cast, Trailer, and Everything Else to Know - TV Guide - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Msica | Anatomy of a Scene - The New York Times - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20, Episode 4 Recap: 8 Biggest Story Reveals - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 Is Coming - IGN - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Gets Another Season | Next TV - Next TV - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy new episode: How to watch for free April 4 - MassLive.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Misses a Major Opportunity with Arizona Robbins' Return - Den of Geek - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- New UN report outlines the 'Anatomy of a Genocide' in Gaza - Mondoweiss - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Arizona Returned to 'Grey's Anatomy,' But Did She Mention Callie? - Henry Herald - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Just Proved Maggie & Winston Won't Be Endgame - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- The Fate of Grey's Anatomy Revealed After 20 Seasons - E! NEWS - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Why Anatomy Of A Fall Is Rated R - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Fans Get a Big Update About the Future of the Show - Gwinnettdailypost.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Anatomy Of A Fall's Best Scene Is A Brutal Reminder Of This Netflix Movie With 95% On Rotten Tomatoes - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- This 'Grey's Anatomy' Death Changed the Series Forever - Collider - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- The Anatomy of An Inning: Kutter Crawford's Offspeed Heavy Debut - Over The Monster - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy': Dr. Bailey's Best Moments From Her Intern Era - Bustle - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' renewed for season 21 - The Hindu - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Are French Courtooms Really Like That? Fact-Checking Anatomy Of A Fall - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- What to Expect When Arizona Robbins Returns to 'Grey's Anatomy' - Gwinnettdailypost.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Why Did Arizona Robbins Leave Grey's Anatomy? What Happened to Jessica Capshaw? - Soaps.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 10 Best Movies Like Anatomy Of A Fall - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- I love Grey's Anatomy but we must call time of death - inews - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Showrunner Explains How They Decide to Bring Certain Characters Back - Just Jared - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- The Best Sandra Hller Movies (Including Anatomy Of A Fall) And How To Watch Them - CinemaBlend - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Will Ellen Pompeo Be in Season 20 of 'Grey's Anatomy'? - Good Housekeeping - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Ellen Pompeo Marks Her Return as Meredith Grey in 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 20 First Look (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Meredith Returns To Seattle In First Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Trailer - Screen Rant - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Greys Anatomy: Ellen Pompeo Returns To Grey Sloan Memorial In Season 20 Teaser; New Updates On Altman, Interns & More Watch - Deadline - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Ellen Pompeo Returns to 'Grey's Anatomy' in Season 20 First Look - Entertainment Tonight - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 20 Teaser Meredith Returns to the OR - Collider - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- ANALYSIS: Anatomy of a slump ... It aint that bad here - Nets Daily - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Anatomy of a botched gangland hit Blanchardstown's nightmare before Christmas - The Irish Times - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Director Justine Triet on 'Anatomy Of A Fall''s nightmare couple and creating one of the year's buzziest scenes - Screen International - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20: Release Date, Cast, Story & Everything We Know - Screen Rant - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Sandra Hller on Breaking a No-Holocaust-Movie Rule for Zone of Interest, and Whether Her Anatomy of a Fall Character Is Guilty - Variety - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- 10 Times Grey's Anatomy Characters Cheated Death - Screen Rant - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Ellen Pompeo is Back as Meredith Grey in 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 20 Promo Watch Now! - Just Jared - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Ellen Pompeo Is Back on Greys Anatomy In Scintillating Season 20 Teaser - Decider - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Season 20 Cast Revealed: 15 Stars Confirmed to Return, 2 Actors Not Coming Back - Just Jared - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- The 10 Best Episodes of 'Grey's Anatomy' of All Time, Ranked From Lowest to Highest Audience Score - Just Jared - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- Gen V, Shoresy, and the Anatomy of 2023's Best Spinoffs - Paste Magazine - December 31st, 2023 [December 31st, 2023]
- How to watch Anatomy of a Fall is it streaming? - Dexerto - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Every 'Grey's Anatomy' Season Is Coming to Hulu - Vulture - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Anatomy of a Fall steals the show at the European Film Awards 2023 - Euronews - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- A Case of Thoraco-Omphalopagus Conjoined Twins: Clinical Imaging and Anatomical Classification - Cureus - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]
- Every Grey's Anatomy Christmas Episode - Screen Rant - December 14th, 2023 [December 14th, 2023]