Screen Grab/C-Span
Democratic Congressman and House Impeachment Manager Joe Neguse
In a well-run courtroom, the judge makes the issues clear: What is the charge? What evidence is important? What do the lawyers need to prove? What does the trier of fact (jury, or judge in a bench trial) need to determine, to resolve the dispute?At the end of the trial, the judge lays out exactly what the jury must decidefor example, did the defendant in fact fire the fatal shot? If so, did the defendant act in self-defense? If it wasnt in self-defense, did the defendant intend to kill the deceased? Was the killing premeditated? And so on.
This weeks Senate proceedings are, as a matter of constitutional text, a trial; but there is no judge to guide the advocates or to provide legal instructions to the Senators who must decide.
Thus, on Friday, the Senate and the nation heard the final evidence in two different casesone laid out by the House in its Article of Impeachment and the accompanying trial brief, and the other rebutted by the lawyers for former President Donald Trump.
The House Article charges that, beginning months before the insurrection of January 6, Trump deliberately lied about the result of the election, attempted through corrupt means to invalidate it, and encouraged violence to prevent the constitutionally required certification of the electoral-vote total. His campaign apparatus spent as much as $50 million to spread the lie via advertising. He contacted state officials in contested states and pressured and threatened in an attempt to get them to set aside the vote and give him the states electoral votes.
As spelled out in the brief and the video evidence, he repeatedly encouraged violence against his political enemies and asked the most dangerous extremists in the country to stand back and stand by. He called his followers to a wild! rally on January 6, at which it was known to all in the government that violence was being planned, and thenaware of the intent of many in the crowd directly told them to march on the Capitol. When they got there, the mob, predictably, turned violentand the Vice President and the Speaker of the House were nearly assassinated. During the most dangerous hours of the assault, while five people were being killed, the President (despite desperate pleas from his allies) remained silent; he refused to call on his loyal insurgents to stop, and he did not dispatch federal law enforcement and military personnel to defend the Capitol, the members of Congress and the besieged U.S. Capitol Police. Afterwards, he sent the insurgents home with praise and the assurance that we love you.
As seen by the prosecution, then, the charge is that Trump engaged in a course of criminal action over months, which involved legitimization of violence, targeting of mass rage, defamation of individuals whose lives were endangered, organization of an insurrectionary gathering, passive acceptance of the violence when under way and then subsequent ratification of it once it was over.
If I were defending Trump from this charge, I would try to do what Trumps lawyersformer Pennsylvania prosecutor Bruce Castor, Alabama litigator David Schoen, and Philadelphia lawyer Michael T. Van der Veenattempted. Faced with vivid evidence of Trumps course of conductcalls for violence, repeated false claims of a stolen election, expenditure of time and money to gather a mob, knowledge that the crowd would be dangerous, and rhetoric that did nothing to discourage the violencethey refused to engage the issue.
All of that stuff, it turns out, is irrelevantDonald Trump, they argue, is being tried for speaking the word fight. And since we all use the word fight, he cant be guilty. Dont believe me? Heres a clip of Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, Nancy Pelosi, Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Chuck Schumer and Madonna and Johnny Depp and (at one point I had to answer the door) probably His Holiness the Dalai Lama all using bad words like fight. To make that clearer, sometimes the video was repeatedly looped so it seemed like the speaker was saying fight five or six times in a row. That proves Trump is innocent. Why? Well, the word fight is a word. Words are speech. The First Amendment protects speech, so Trump can say fight.
Constricting the time frame of events is a time-honored lawyers tactic. In a courtroom, judges may put some limits on the freedom to distort the chronological frame of a criminal indictment. But here, the case is put to the Senate (and, equally important, the nation) as two different cases; if the past few years are any guide, it will be analyzed purely according to the pre-existing political commitments of the listeners.
In their first appearance on Tuesday, February 9, the Trump legal team proved incapable of even laying out that argument. Instead, they described a terrifying threat: One day a trial-happy Senate would come back and impeach Eric Holder. On Friday, having had time to recoup, they did get the he-said-fight argument in outline form. To them, they say, the only question is whether when Trump said fight like hell to the rally on January 6, these words were (1) unprotected by the First Amendment and (2) so powerful that they created a blood-crazed zombie mob that surprised everyone by assaulting the Capitol.
Thus posed, of course, the answer must be no. Trumps behavior, as he claimed, was totally appropriate and its just one a jolly bad break that the criminals in the mob chose at that precise moment to run wild and engage in acts that no one deplored more than Donald Trump himself.
Its very hard to believe that the defense presentation changed a single mind. Members of the House and Senate themselves were present on January 6 (as the defense team was not). Members of Congress know what happened. Many of the were terrified and appalled; remarkably many, however, found the breach of the Capitol to be just part of a working day that began with a spurious challenge to the electoral votes from Arizona and thenafter an interlude of violence and bloodended in a similar false challenge to the electoral votes from Pennsylvania. The aim of those challengers and the rioters alike was cancelling the results of the 2020 election. The means chosen were different; for some, parliamentary motions, for others, stun guns, bear mace, zip ties, clubs and spears, and a gallows. But the intent was the same. Theres no evidence that most of the challengers repent their actions; nor is there evidence that Donald Trump feels anything but perhaps regret that the insurrection failed.
This is the way to understand the contention that the First Amendments free speech clause bars the conviction of Donald Trump. Theres no doubt that Trump could tell his followers to fight. He might even use the word several times. And look! Look! Democrats say the word fight too!
But the charge is not limited to one speech on January 6. It is of a plan, and perhaps a full-fledged criminal conspiracy, initiated months before and moved forward with communications, organization, finance, and political support from Trump and his White House, which involved repeated lies and corrupt behind-the-scenes maneuvers and led predictably to a violent assault that came close to destroying our Congress.
The First Amendment doesnt cover planning, financing, organizing, and inciting an armed attack on the United States. If you are convinced by the Houses evidence, then you will favor conviction. Or you can look the other way because what about Nancy Pelosi. Those are your choices.
Follow this link:
Anatomy of an Insurrection - Washington Monthly
- Of course, Grey's Anatomy has the perfect formula to make viewers cry - The A.V. Club - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Delivered the Greatest Star Wars Reference of All-Time - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Shondaland EP Wants Pitches for Next Spin-Off - TheWrap - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Video: 'Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes' | Anatomy of a Scene - The New York Times - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Anatomy professor receives NWC Teaching Excellence Award - Northwestern College - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Anatomy of a scroll: Inside TikTok's AI-powered algorithms - POLITICO Europe - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- The Anatomy of a University's Encampment Negotiation - The Chronicle of Higher Education - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Alexis Floyd on Simone Hitting 'Rock Bottom' (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Researchers map out anatomy of wooden breast syndrome in broiler chickens - Phys.org - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Season 20, Episode 7, "She Used to Be Mine," Recap & Spoilers - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: The Kai Bartley Character Explained (& Where You've Seen The Actor) - Screen Rant - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Subtly Confirms Simone & Lucas Still Have A Future Together - Screen Rant - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Ross Procedure Outcomes in Children Tied to Anatomy - Newswise - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Explore the Props That Give 'Grey's Anatomy' Its Edge - Shondaland.com - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Can science explain why couples break up? The mathematical anatomy of a fall - The Conversation - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Is Greys Anatomy on tonight (May 9, 2024)? Episode details for She Used to Be Mine - Gold Derby - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Still Hasn't Topped One of Its Earliest Seasons - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- What the Craziest Cases on 'Grey's Anatomy' Can Teach You About Playing a Patient - Backstage - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- A Beloved Grey's Anatomy Character Was Way More Problematic Than Fans Will Admit - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- How a Village Comes to Life in 'Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes' - The New York Times - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' and 'The Resident' Dominate This Week's Streaming Top 10 - Collider - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Has Finally Found Its Cristina Yang Replacement After 10 Years - Screen Rant - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- 10 Best Grey's Anatomy Friendships, Ranked - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- The Best Grey's Anatomy Cliffhangers, Ranked - CBR - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Recap 05/09/24: Season 20 Episode 7 She Used to Be Mine - Celebrity Dirty Laundry - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Lexie Grey Originally Had a Way Worse Death on 'Grey's Anatomy' - Collider - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- 'Anatomy of a Murder' Kicked Off Our Obsession With True Crime - Collider - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: How Simone's 'Rock Bottom' Moment Will Change Her Going Forward, According to Alexis Floyd - CinemaBlend - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Has Dropped A Crucial Plotline That Needs To Return In Season 21 - Screen Rant - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- The anatomy of imperfection: Inside Stefano Colferai's playful stop motion animations of everyday life - It's Nice That - May 12th, 2024 [May 12th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy': Meredith's Family Emergency Brings Up the Past - PEOPLE - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Cristina Yang's Return Prospect Gets Honest Response From Sandra Oh - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' recap: Is Jo pregnant? - Entertainment Weekly News - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Shonda Rhimes had police protect her after 'Grey's Anatomy' finales - Business Insider - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Most Enduring Character Is a Real-Life Scrub Nurse - CBR - Comic Book Resources - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Civil War | Anatomy of a Scene - The New York Times - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- How Frances Anatomy of a Fall Scored a Theatrical Release in China and Connected With Its Elusive Indie Audience - Variety - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Station 19 Season 7 Just Reversed A Major Grey's Anatomy Story With Sully & Natasha - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Why Sandra Oh Doesn't Plan to Return to 'Grey's Anatomy' 'Anytime Soon' - PEOPLE - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Confirms A Fatal Flaw In Meredith's Story After 20 Seasons - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Jo Is 'Spiraling' from Pregnancy News (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Would Sandra Oh ever come back to 'Grey's Anatomy'? - New York Post - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Why Did Sarah Drew Leave Grey's Anatomy? - CBR - Comic Book Resources - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- How to watch Greys Anatomy season 20 episode 5 for free - MassLive.com - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20, Episode 5 Recap: 6 Biggest Story Reveals - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- How Shonda Rhimes Celebrated the 20th Season of 'Grey's Anatomy' And Yet Another History-Making Moment for ... - Shondaland.com - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Station 19: Ben & Carina's Grey's Anatomy Futures Carefully Teased By Showrunner - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- 10 Best Ellen Pompeo Movie and TV Show Roles That Aren't Grey's Anatomy - CBR - Comic Book Resources - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Cristina Yang's Return Prospect Gets Honest Response From Sandra Oh - imdb - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy: Meredith Was Missing Derek After Son's Medical Emergency, But Here's Why I Think She And Nick ... - CinemaBlend - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- The Anatomy of An Inning: Brayan Bello Attacks the A's - Over The Monster - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- A slice of life inside the Human Anatomy Lab at Cal Poly - Mustang News - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- SynthFest France 2024 coming April 19-21 with Synth Anatomy video coverage - Synth Anatomy - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy's Sandra Oh weighs in on Christina Yang return - Digital Spy - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Just Teased The Show's Next Great Couple - Screen Rant - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- The Art of Medieval Anatomy with Taylor McCall - Medievalists.net - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Anatomy of a Fall Actor Samuel Theis Accused of Rape by Crew Member on New Film - Yahoo Movies Canada - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Anatomy Of A Recession Update: What's Different About This Cycle? - Seeking Alpha - April 15th, 2024 [April 15th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy Renewed For Season 21 By ABC - Deadline - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy to highlight Baton Rouge baby's rare medical case Thursday night - WBRZ - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- A Refresher on What Happened to Arizona on 'Grey's Anatomy' - Parade Magazine - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- How the 'Grey's Anatomy' Crew Works With Real-Life Doctors to Bring The Most Complicated Procedures to TV - Shondaland.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 (ABC): What We Know So Far - Parade Magazine - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20: Premiere Date, Cast, Trailer, and Everything Else to Know - TV Guide - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Msica | Anatomy of a Scene - The New York Times - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20, Episode 4 Recap: 8 Biggest Story Reveals - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 21 Is Coming - IGN - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Gets Another Season | Next TV - Next TV - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Greys Anatomy new episode: How to watch for free April 4 - MassLive.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Misses a Major Opportunity with Arizona Robbins' Return - Den of Geek - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- New UN report outlines the 'Anatomy of a Genocide' in Gaza - Mondoweiss - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Arizona Returned to 'Grey's Anatomy,' But Did She Mention Callie? - Henry Herald - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Just Proved Maggie & Winston Won't Be Endgame - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- The Fate of Grey's Anatomy Revealed After 20 Seasons - E! NEWS - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Why Anatomy Of A Fall Is Rated R - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy' Fans Get a Big Update About the Future of the Show - Gwinnettdailypost.com - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- Anatomy Of A Fall's Best Scene Is A Brutal Reminder Of This Netflix Movie With 95% On Rotten Tomatoes - Screen Rant - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- This 'Grey's Anatomy' Death Changed the Series Forever - Collider - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- The Anatomy of An Inning: Kutter Crawford's Offspeed Heavy Debut - Over The Monster - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]
- 'Grey's Anatomy': Dr. Bailey's Best Moments From Her Intern Era - Bustle - April 7th, 2024 [April 7th, 2024]